
A natural deodorant can contain aluminium, even when the packaging states that the product is free of aluminium chlorohydrate. How can that be? It comes down to the different aluminium compounds used in deodorants.
For many people, deodorant is a natural part of their morning routine. A quick roll or spray, and you’re done. Yet, there are significant differences between products that appear similar at first glance. One reduces body odour, while another inhibits sweat production. And a deodorant marketed as natural doesn’t necessarily have to be aluminium-free.
After Arnaud was diagnosed with melanoma in 2024, we started looking more consciously at nutrition, lifestyle, and the products we use daily. Deodorant also came under scrutiny. What’s in it, why are certain ingredients added, and what do we know about the possible consequences for our health?
Why is there aluminium in deodorant?
To understand that, we first need to distinguish between deodorant and antiperspirant.
Fresh sweat is largely odourless. The familiar underarm odour primarily arises when bacteria on the skin break down substances from sweat and skin secretions.
A deodorant targets that odour, for example, by using fragrances or influencing the activity of odour-forming bacteria. An antiperspirant, on the other hand, reduces the amount of sweat that reaches the skin.
This is usually done with aluminium compounds, such as aluminium chlorohydrate. These aluminium compounds temporarily block the upper part of the sweat ducts, reducing the amount of sweat that reaches the skin’s surface.
Some products combine both functions. Therefore, the name on the front of the packaging doesn’t always tell you exactly what a product does.
Is aluminium harmful to your health?
Aluminium occurs naturally in our environment. We ingest small amounts of it through food and drinking water, among other sources. Certain cosmetic products also contain aluminium compounds.
At high exposure, aluminium can have harmful effects, including on the nervous system and bones. People with severely impaired kidney function are particularly vulnerable because their bodies are less able to excrete aluminium.
But how much aluminium from an antiperspirant actually enters the body?
A 2018 study estimated the average skin absorption to be approximately 0.0094% of the applied amount. A follow-up study in 2022, using a refined measurement method, found it to be approximately 0.00052%.
Both studies concerned specific antiperspirant formulations. Therefore, the results do not automatically apply to every deodorant or aluminium compound.
The European Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) has evaluated aluminium compounds in cosmetics and concluded that the investigated applications can be safely used within established concentration limits.
What about breast cancer?
For years, research has been conducted into whether aluminium-containing antiperspirants can increase the risk of breast cancer. This question arose partly because these products are applied close to breast tissue.
In laboratory research, effects of certain aluminium compounds on cells have been observed. However, such results do not automatically mean that the daily use of antiperspirants causes cancer in humans.
A 2024 analysis of seven studies comparing people with and without breast cancer found no statistically significant association between the use of underarm products and breast cancer. However, the available studies had limitations.
The American National Cancer Institute and the American Cancer Society also state that there is currently no convincing scientific evidence for a link between antiperspirants and breast cancer.
Natural deodorant can also contain aluminium
Those who prefer to use natural personal care products often encounter deodorants with the ingredient Potassium Alum.
Potassium alum is a mineral salt that contains aluminium. It is used in mineral deodorants and products marketed as natural, among others.
Chemically, potassium alum differs from aluminium chlorohydrate, the compound commonly found in regular antiperspirants. But both contain aluminium.
Therefore, packaging stating ‘aluminium chlorohydrate-free’ can be accurate, even if the product contains potassium alum. The claim refers to one specific compound and not to aluminium in general.
There is also insufficient evidence that potassium alum leads to lower aluminium absorption through the skin simply because it is naturally derived. This would require data on the specific formulation and on absorption through the skin.
The word ‘natural’ itself therefore says little about the safety of a deodorant.
And what else is in it?
In addition to aluminium compounds, many deodorants contain ingredients that reduce odour, care for the skin, or give the product a certain scent.
Fragrances, in particular, can cause skin irritation or contact allergies in some people. This also applies to certain essential oils. An ingredient from a plant is not automatically milder for the skin.
The underarm skin is also sensitive to moisture, friction, and shaving. This can cause a product to sting or cause redness more quickly, especially if the skin is already irritated.
Ingredients such as alcohol, baking soda, and certain acids are also found in deodorants. How the skin reacts to these differs per person and per formulation.
What do we use ourselves?
We currently use Salt of the Earth Natural Deodorant and a natural roll-on deodorant from Happy Earth. We switch between the two and are happy with how they work for us.
When we delved further into the ingredients, we discovered that the variants we use contain potassium alum. Although they are marketed as natural deodorants, they are therefore not aluminium-free.
That got us thinking. We are satisfied with these products, but we also want to explore what alternatives exist without aluminium compounds, with a clear ingredient list, and effective against body odour.
For now, we’re continuing to use our current deodorants. The available research gives us no reason to consider them unsafe, but we’re still exploring alternatives that better match our preferences.
In the Leef in Regie Starter Guide, we look more closely at products you use every day, including deodorant, make-up and hair dye.
Sources
- National Cancer Institute – explanation of the difference between deodorants and antiperspirants, aluminium as an active ingredient in antiperspirants, and the lack of convincing evidence for a link to breast cancer: https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/myths/antiperspirants-fact-sheet
- American Cancer Society – overview of scientific research on aluminium-containing antiperspirants, skin absorption, and the possible link to breast cancer: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/risk-prevention/chemicals/antiperspirants-and-breast-cancer-risk.html
- Systematic review and meta-analysis (2024) – analysis of seven patient-control studies on the use of underarm products and the risk of breast cancer; no statistically significant association was found: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39324502/
- Clinical and Translational Science (2018) – human study on the skin absorption of aluminium from an antiperspirant with aluminium chlorohydrate; the estimated average absorption was approximately 0.0094%: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6226111/
- Research on skin absorption of aluminium (2022) – follow-up study with a refined measurement method, where the estimated average absorption from the investigated antiperspirant formulation was approximately 0.00052%: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9244721/
- Happy Earth – product information and ingredient list for the Natural Deodorant Roller Unscented, including potassium alum: https://www.happyearthcare.com/en/collections/natuurlijke-verzorgingsproducten/products/happy-earth-deodorant-roller-unscented-75ml